Tciso wrote: ↑Tue Mar 14, 2023 6:36 am
Ok Chef. Tell us what your re-build looks like from where we are today.
I wouldn’t mind you explaining what a rebuild is?
There’s a segment of fan bases around the league and some media who use this as a fall back path to success and any chance of winning the Cup…
Because rebuilds are the obvious way to build a winning team, there must be many, many examples of teams who have taken the scorch earth approach and won a Cup, right?
I asked a very adamant and vocal rebuild advocate the question and he gave the Penguins as an example..
An organization which drafted 5th, 1st, 2nd, 1st, 2nd, overall in 5 consecutive drafts starting in 2002 and were lucky enough that players like Fleury, Malkin and a generational talent Crosby were available in those drafts…
But to his credit they did win the Cup 3 times, the first in 2009 and two more in 2016 and 2017 thanks to a number of key acquisitions by trade because their days of drafting at the head of the line were long over…
I asked him how long do these rebuilds generally take?
And if rebuilding is a guaranteed path to success, how come there haven’t been more teams winning the Cup and why are teams like the Sabres who haven’t been to the playoffs since 2011 still rebuilding?
And how did the advent of the salary cap in 2005 impact the ability for teams to stockpile and keep blue chip prospects?
What impact does the disappearance of the second contract have on teams ability to stockpile and keep blue chip prospects?
Teams like the Penguins, Hawks and more recently the Bolts acquired a core of 4 or 5 elite players and then filled their rosters with JAG’s because those elite core players took away their teams ability to draft at the head of the class and when you go back and look over their draft history, you will find a very, very high rate of misses with the odd hit….
They cycled JAG’s in and out of their rosters as they tap danced the salary cap and at the end of the day they began to fade away from being serious contenders as their elite core began to play on the back 9 of their careers…
So for me, the take away is that you keep rebuilding until you luck out (especially now with the draft lottery system) and draft a core of elite players whom you can build your team around by way of draft, development, trades and signings…
And you want your elite core to include a goalie, dman and centre as a must…
What then should Vancouver do? should it be all in on Demko, Hughes and EP or should it roll the dice on a full rebuild and hope to draft better players down the road?
Because with those 3 players being healthy the team will have a very hard time tanking and being so bad that their odds are so high that they get the 1at or even 2nd overall picks in consecutive years or over a 5 year stretch….
Or do you do what this management group is trying to do? Build around your elite core with draft picks, an emphasis on better development, signing and trades?
Unless I misunderstand what a rebuild is, I see the path this management group taking is the obvious and thank the former management group for bringing Demko, EP and Hughes into the organization…
Take care…