Re: Hughes Traded Thread
Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2025 4:41 pm
Chef is still unwinding from his foray into the politics thread.... He'll level out soon, and start abiding.
Maybe you need my avatar.Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 4:12 pmSure fucktard, point out where it was said in post before mine where “Allvin asked Rutherford to help”? I’m seeing something where Guerin said as such, but not “why” he was told to deal with Rutherford.JelloPuddingPop wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 12:55 pmLike in the post right before yours?Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 12:20 pm It was revealed that Allvin asked Jim Rutherford to help him with the Hughes trade
Now fuck off
Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 4:12 pmSure fucktard, point out where it was said in post before mine where “Allvin asked Rutherford to help”? I’m seeing something where Guerin said as such, but not “why” he was told to deal with Rutherford.JelloPuddingPop wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 12:55 pmLike in the post right before yours?Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Wed Dec 17, 2025 12:20 pm It was revealed that Allvin asked Jim Rutherford to help him with the Hughes trade
Now fuck off

Very few players are on the same talent level as Hughes, nobody on this team was/is. When you pan the league you have the Crosby, MacKinnon, McDavid, realm. Then the tier that includes Matthews, Draisaitl, Kucherov, Kaprizov, Hughes, and Makar.....probably a few others, but not many. Quinn and Makar are the best two defensemen in the game right now, both of them are top-10 players, and I'd give Hughes the edge because he has had to drive his team without a guy like MacKinnon helping him the way he has Makar.Todd Bersnoozi wrote: ↑Thu Dec 18, 2025 9:23 pm At first when the Huggy trade happened it didn't seem like we made out with very much. Having sat back for a few days, it has grown on me a bit. Been hearing good things about Buium. Sounds like he was key to our mgmt to make the deal. He probably will never be as good as Huggy, but if he can become like a Werenski/C.Hutson calibre player, it will be great trade. He basically projects like one of those American prep school kids taking the NHL by storm, great skaters and high skill. Rossi is ok, not sure we need another small, dinky, skilled guy, but at least he can play centre. He'll easily be our most skilled C after EP40. It was nice getting a 1st in the deal, albeit a late one. Don't expect much out of Ohgren, but give him a chance, u never know. He was also a former 1st rounder.
This core was toast the minute they traded Horvat and went with JT and EP as the top-6 pivots. Nobody could see it then, but hindsight is 20/20. They needed to decide at that point between Pettersson and Miller because it was apparently recognized at the time that those two guys were never going to get along. When it came to a head and Miller was traded the core was already poisoned. I do think it could have been salvaged if Pettersson had been the one dealt.....the stories of the friendship between Miller, Boeser, Hughes, Myers, and Garland, lead me to think that they were the nucleus that the rest of the team revolved around, and Pettersson was an ionized/ionizing particle. But what's done is done.Man, gotta say though, with Huggy gone, it pretty much means the end of this core for this team. Couple yrs ago when we had that core of Huggy, Petey, Brock, JT, Demmer, I thought this core would make for the best ever Nucks team. I thought this core would be better than 94 & 2011 teams. The only thing was JT was on the older side.
If any team would ever bring Lord Stanley to Vancouver, I thought those guys would be it. With only 2 playoff appearances from that core, it has to be the most disappointing Nucks team ever. So much potential, but so much dysfunction and lack of success as well.![]()
The guy plays some smart hockey - but I think needs more talent on his wings.Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Tue Dec 30, 2025 8:06 am Your thoughts on Rossi, so far? So far he’s looking like a nothing burger. Did Guerin pull a fast one us the way Phoenix pulled a fast one on Benning regarding the OEL trade?
Ohgren? A different story, like what I see of the kid.
Are we setting ourselves up for disappointment with over praising Buium? I worry we are expecting too much out of the kid, he’s alright.
The Minny pick is currently 30th overall.
Guerin may have pulled a nasty on Allvin and Rutherford once the dust settles, time will tell.
In Canucks terms, Rossi is a Swiss BMo.JelloPuddingPop wrote: ↑Tue Dec 30, 2025 9:25 amThe guy plays some smart hockey - but I think needs more talent on his wings.Chef Boi RD wrote: ↑Tue Dec 30, 2025 8:06 am Your thoughts on Rossi, so far? So far he’s looking like a nothing burger. Did Guerin pull a fast one us the way Phoenix pulled a fast one on Benning regarding the OEL trade?
Ohgren? A different story, like what I see of the kid.
Are we setting ourselves up for disappointment with over praising Buium? I worry we are expecting too much out of the kid, he’s alright.
The Minny pick is currently 30th overall.
Guerin may have pulled a nasty on Allvin and Rutherford once the dust settles, time will tell.
Smart guy like that, playing with McKenna on one wing and Nikita Klepov on the other - and he will put up points.
Plavsic was a defenseman…..so I’m thinking more a Craig Coxe/Doug Wickenheiser.
Nothing wrong with a BMo type center if you have dominant puck-hogging play-driving winger(s) like our own WCE, Boldy Kaprizov, Kucherov, Pat Kane, Marner, etc. In fact, you want that type of center who is still offensively very good but willing and capable of the dirty work. Toews is another.
As I said, no slight intended towards BMo (or Rossi)…..for the reasons you state.Carl Yagro wrote: ↑Tue Dec 30, 2025 1:07 pmNothing wrong with a BMo type center if you have dominant puck-hogging play-driving winger(s) like our own WCE, Boldy Kaprizov, Kucherov, Pat Kane, Marner, etc. In fact, you want that type of center who is still offensively very good but willing and capable of the dirty work. Toews is another.
Fans keep thinking it's an ASG, but there's only so much puck to go around. It just doesn't work long term.
Remember when the twins took over? Everyone was salivating over Naslund as their RW. Guess what? Naslund was crying like a baby when he could no longer pound the puck into the ice or run the half-boards. He had to find open spots for Sedin passes which was not his game at all.