Thursday, November 27th, 2014

Dudline Day

7

Three points to make:

1) What a bust. I think Chicago helped themselves by grabbing Pahlsson. I think that was the only really good deal made by a team in the hunt. I don’t suppose anybody will remember this next year in the hype running up to next year’s dudline.

2) Toronto paid about $650,000 for a fourth round draft pick. This is a ridiculous overpay in my opinion so I suppose Brian Burke thinks the prospect he acquired is worth a few hundred thousand more than the prospect he gave up. 

All the whispers about the Tampa Bay financial situation seem to be confirmed by the deal and the fact that the league let it go through.

3) I’m delighted by the Calgary decision to trade Matthew Lombardi for Olli Jokinen. I figure this one as a no lose for Canuck fans.

Is Sutter mad? He was asked whether Mike Keenan was influential in making the decision given his history in Florida. Sutter said something like, “No. In fact, we didn’t get serious about it until last night and I didn’t talk to him at all.” 

He didn’t get serious about this until last night? It was a secret that Jokinen would be available? This decision wasn’t carefully made weeks ago? I guess not. That’s nuts.

Anybody who knows my taste in hockey players knows that I love Matthew Lombardi. I think he is a really good player, a guy who is far better than his statistics. Jokinen’s value is in his statistics. Even if I grant that Jokinen is a better player, I would never have traded these two players even up let alone throwing in a first round pick simply because Calgary was an outstanding team without making a trade. Me, I don’t fundamentally change an outstanding team.

My first premise is that it is very difficult to improve a very good team. At best, it can only be marginally improved. It is surprisingly easy to make an outstanding team worse and it can be a lot more than marginally worse. Surely Sutter’s first priority is to make sure he does not screw it up.

The Flames are going to be a very different team. I think it is very unlikely they will be a better different team. If Jokinen doesn’t fit in or the other players affected don’t adjust well to their new roles they will be a worse different team.

Thanks, Daryl.

Be Sociable, Share!

Comments

7 Responses to “Dudline Day”
  1. Cameron says:

    The Jokinen deal for Calgary is simply huge. They have lacked a true #1 pivot for more than a decade, and Jokinen fits the Calgary mold to a ‘T’. He’s got the prototype size, speed and skills (especially playmaking ability) to be a draft-horse on the first line.

    Under Keenan Jokinen’s numbers (on a terrible team) climbed steadily from 29 points to a high of 91.

    Meanwhile Lombardi has already peaked offensively and is now a multi-purpose checker destined to forever tease with 50 point potential only to deliver a steady 35. He’s Paul Ranheim for the new age. A useful foot-soldier, but never someone who will be a game-decider.

    So chuckle at Sutter’s move all you want, but Jokinen is exactly what the doctor ordered for the Flames.

  2. Magicpie says:

    He was asked whether Mike Keenan was influential in making the decision given his history in Florida. Sutter said something like, “No. In fact, we didn’t get serious about it until last night and I didn’t talk to him at all.”

    I guess NHL GMs are basically just like procrastinating college students. “Oh shit, the deadline’s tommorow? Better stay up all night and work something out”

  3. Tom says:

    So chuckle at Sutter’s move all you want, but Jokinen is exactly what the doctor ordered for the Flames.

    I don’t think this is a bad analogy. In this case, the quack performed radical surgery on a patient that was in excellent health.

    We’ll see how it works out. I say that, at best, the patient is still healthy.

  4. Scott says:

    Given that Sutter also flatly denied that the Flames were looking for a top line forward or a defender the day before the deadline would seem to suggest he probably shouldn’t be taken at his word with these things.

    Also, I think it’s important not to overlook the fact that the Flames also got Leopold at the deadline, a player that some of the Flames already know and should be able to help them going forward.

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. [...] Benjamin didn’t like the Calgary move trading Lombardi and crew for Jokinen.  Don’t agree at all.  I think [...]

  2. [...] thought Daryl Sutter was mad to trade for Olli Jokinen a year ago and I think he is mad to now trade Jokinen for Kotalik and Higgins. I don’t think [...]

  3. [...] In Cowtown – Even though I thought Daryl Sutter was nuts to trade for Olli Jokinen and then crazy to trade him, Sutter’s decision to bring him back does make some sense to me. [...]



Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!