There’s a spot for Hughes. He has to earn it.Strangelove wrote: ↑Wed Mar 20, 2019 8:43 pmEdler - TanevMëds wrote: ↑Tue Mar 19, 2019 8:49 am Yeah I think that's pretty much the point that UW made there about the "x-factor" free agents.
The difference between a draft pick and a free agent is that the free agent steps in and can play at the NHL level now.
The Canucks are at the point in the rebuild where meaningful games in March are critical. The new core is forming, many of the pieces are settling in, but unless we want to be Edmonton 2.0 we need to actually go into that free agent pool and put some talented veteran players in the mix with Pettersson, Boeser, and Horvat.
We've "homegrown" a goaltender in Markstrom who looks like he's finally the real deal, and because he hit his stride here and was given the opportunity to grow through failures, even if his current play remains status quo for him next year we are likely to see him give Vancouver a legit discount next spring (Swedes seem to be pretty loyal.....I'll give them that Per ).
We do NOT have the pieces on the roster or in the system to put a reliable NHL blueline on the ice next year.
Edler and Hutton are the only legit top-4 guys we have that we should go forward with, and both need new contracts this summer. Hutton hasn't proven anything though, he's had two good NHL seasons, both in contract years.
Tanev should be traded. His durability is too much of a question mark, and he is $4.5M of cap space that would get us a worthwhile return that comes "cap free".
Stecher is not a top-4 guy. If he can be given a LS partner who can play 15+ min and bring some own-zone smarts and muscle without a propensity for turnovers and useless off-the-glass "transition passes" then he's serviceable on the 3rd pairing and can step up when needed, but he's not a guy that I want as a regular in the top-4, and he's not a guy that you put a rookie defenseman with. Given the right trade I would still move on.
Hughes and Juolevi may not even be ready for the big time. We can't bank on a couple of kids who have yet to suit up for a regular season game in the NHL.
Our trade chips that we should be willing to part with.....
Tanev, Sutter, Eriksson, Spooner, and Baertschi.
We aren't going to address the right-side D spot in a trade involving Tanev. That's just not a hockey trade, RS for RS? Only happens when the team wanting to upgrade finds a team that has extra and pays out a good prospect or pick. Not an option here.
The other 4 names aren't going to get us a top-4 RS blueliner unless they too are part of a package where we send out picks and/or prospects.....which would be stupid at this point.
So.....
Edler - _______
Hutton - _______
______ - Stecher
We have 3 spots that badly need to be filled with players who can perform at a level that actually lets our young leaders win games.
IF we can get out from under $10M of contracts, then target Karlsson AND Myers. Bring in both. The PP and PK are instantly improved. Our 5-on-5 game takes a massive step forward because suddenly we can defend, transition, and attack, with 2/3 of our pairings, maybe all of them depending who lands with Stecher in this scenario.
Where do you suggest we go to get those badly needed spots, the draft? Utica?
Or is the master plan to toil in perpetuity and grow up a core after core of perennial losers like the Oilers have for the better part of two decades?
Hutton - Stecher
Hughes - Tryamkin
With LS Juolevi and RS Woo likely ready within one to two years.
Not sure why you trade Tanev other than to justify your Karlsson AND Myers fantasy (zero chance btw).
Also both will require NMCs... meaning you'd have to protect them in the expansion draft.
In the expansion draft there's a good chance we'll want to protect Juolevi + Tryamkin + one other.
Also you are the only fan in Canuckdom who isn't penciling Hughes into the top 6 next year.
You keep pencilling Tryamkin in. It’s time for an avatar bet Doc.
I’m saying Tryamkin will NOT be on the Canucks next season. We will go until Dec 31? Loser runs with whatever avatar the winner picks for the balance of the season.